Measure 1
California Entity Political Spending Act
Measure 1 would stop corporations, unions and nonprofits from spending their money to help or defeat candidates or ballot measures in California’s local, state and federal elections. The Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision said the government can’t ban that kind of spending. But these organizations exist because state law creates them, and they have only the powers the state gives them. Measure 1 would take election spending off that list. Individuals could still give, spend and speak as they do today.
How the idea works
The Montana Plan starts from how corporations, unions and nonprofits come to exist: state law creates them, and they have only the powers the state grants. Citizens United stops the government from banning their election spending. The Montana Plan would not ban it. It would stop granting the power to spend in elections at all. Measure 1 would do the same in California. Questions about the legal approach
Who it covers
Corporations (for-profit and nonprofit), LLCs and similar businesses, and unincorporated associations, including labor unions. It would not cover candidates, governments, tribal governments or political committees funded by individuals.
No out-of-state loophole
The same definition would apply evenly to every artificial entity doing business in California, wherever it was incorporated.
What organizations could still do
- Research and publish on any candidate or measure, at any time
- Endorse and take positions on their own websites, publications, email lists and unpaid social media
- Speak through their officers and regular staff in interviews, press conferences and testimony
- Communicate with their own members, owners and employees
- Lobby, petition regulators and educate the public on issues
- Run nonpartisan voter registration and debates
What organizations could not do with treasury funds
- Contribute to candidates or campaign committees, including in-kind
- Pay for ads supporting or opposing candidates or measures, including boosted posts
- Pay influencers, celebrities, consultants or other outsiders to advocate
- Pay petition circulators
- Give gifts or other inducements for support, signatures or votes
- Route money through another group for any of the above
People keep every right
Individuals would remain free to speak, donate, volunteer and organize, including through political committees funded by individuals.
Political committees funded by voluntary contributions
Any organization could sponsor one political committee funded only by voluntary contributions from individuals. Dues and other treasury funds could not be used, directly or through a PAC or super PAC. The committee would register and report like any political committee.
Enforcement
Measure 1 would be enforced through ordinary corporate law. It is not a criminal law. Spending beyond an entity’s powers would be void. The entity would lose the privileges the state grants it, such as limited liability, until it repays the amount it spent and certifies that it will comply. The Attorney General and the courts would enforce it, with no new bureaucracy.
Fallback
If the Supreme Court strikes down the core of the measure, or a court issues an injunction, a fallback would take effect automatically. Boards and owners or members would have to approve an annual political budget, and any expenditure of $10,000 or more would have to be reported publicly within 10 days.